Friday, April 13, 2018

This Time for Keeps (1947), 6 Color

Expected to follow his opera star father into the business, but discontent with his life; a young man pursues a career in popular music and romances the aquatic-ballet dancer he met during his time in the service.
1h 45min | Musical, Romance | 17 October 1947
Director: Richard Thorpe
Stars: Esther Williams, Lauritz Melchior, Jimmy Durante, Xavier Cugat, May Whitty.
Stanley Donen ... choreographer

https://www.imdb.com/title/tt0039898/

The young man in question, played by Johnny Johnston, has 9 film acting credits ('42-'56); this is the 6th. 7 of his films are music/als; I didn't notice him before, but he sang That Old Black Magic in Star Spangled Rhythm ('42).

For music, we get lots of opera, lots of Cugat, lots of Durante, plus 1 Cole Porter tune, Easy to Love, sung at least 3 times in the film, at least once while EW swims pretty but alone in ch4; she's in the pool with her niece in ch24 when she gets the second serenade.

We get a bit of dancing in ch8, but nothing to get excited about.

We get an aquacade in ch11, shown on the poster above. 

I should start a list of musicals where the offspring doesn't want to follow the family business and/or the parent/guardian's wishes, and wants to sing/dance instead. Entry 1: The Jazz Singer ('27). What would be a nice brief title for that list? Maybe "I Gotta Singa!"? But will I really go through all these musicals again to capture such a list? Maybe when I'm deciding which musicals to re-watch in round 2. Other list(s) should be Musical Comedies of Deception, Musical Comedies of Misunderstanding.

This film has too much plot, not enough aquacade.

MGM, dir. Thorpe; 6