Wednesday, December 13, 2017

In Old Chicago (1938), 7

The O'Leary brothers -- honest Jack and roguish Dion -- become powerful figures, and eventually rivals, in Chicago on the eve of its Great Fire.
(95 min theatrical release, 111 min roadshow) Released 1938-01-06
Director: Henry King
Stars: Tyrone Power, Alice Faye, Don Ameche, Alice Brady
Nick Castle ... dance director (uncredited)
Jack Haskell ... dance director (uncredited)
Geneva Sawyer ... dance director (uncredited)

Genres: Action | Drama | Musical | Romance

No idea why they needed 3 dance directors; perhaps for the crowd scenes during the campaigning and during the fire? There were performances by chorus girls onstage at the music halls, and AF danced with them once or twice. But if the dance director Oscar were still active, I can't imagine this would get nom'd. Frankly, I question whether this deserves a Musical tag; Music seems better. As I said in the last post, I like AF's singing when she's selling it to the crowd, and she does that here.  

The 7 is for the fire. Remember Gone With the Wind (1939) is the following year. The assistant director (2nd unit?) won the Oscar, likely for the fire. (Alice Brady, playing the mother, won for Supporting Actress.) Good thing I rated this previously; watching it as a musical does not inspire a 7 rating. But I'll leave it, because I remembered this was a fire epic, and it was even better than I remembered.

Always a pleasure to see our 3 stars. Weird to have 2 AF movies in a row, but the December release was by Universal, and the Fox date was the premiere, 3 months in advance of the wide release.

Watched the roadshow (longer) version first; no idea what they cut to remove 16 minutes.

Right now this film is designated as (1937), but has no release date before Jan '38. I just reported that to IMDb.

Fox, dir. King; 7

Tuesday, December 12, 2017

You're a Sweetheart (1937), 6+

Hal Adams tries to win the heart of Broadway star Betty Bradley.
(96 min) Released 1937-12-26
Director: David Butler
Stars: Alice Faye, George Murphy, Ken Murray
Carl Randall ... choreographer

Genres: Musical | Romance
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0029809/
Watched online; worst video quality imaginable.

It's hard to judge this film, given that I could only recognize Alice Faye by voice in some scenes.

I liked AF playing a performer, selling her song onstage.

Some of the jokes were actually funny to me.

I think George Murphy confirmed my recent theory: he dances better when he doesn't feel intimidated by "better" dancers. He and AF dance a couple of times, and he gets pretty athletic. This might even belong on my "worthwhile dancing" list, but without a watchable copy, I won't go there.

I'd really like to see a good print of this. But it's from Universal, and they don't seem to want to share their musicals. I'll keep it on my wishlist.

Universal, dir. Butler; 6+

Wake Up and Live (1937), 6-

Satire on radio, built around the supposed feud between bandleader Ben Bernie and journalist Walter Winchell.
(91 min) Released 1937-08-07
Director: Sidney Lanfield
Stars: Walter Winchell, Ben Bernie, Alice Faye, Jack Haley, Patsy Kelly, Ned Sparks, The Condos Brothers
Jack Haskell ... choreographer

Genres: Musical
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0029744/

Immediately after the credits we get The Condos Brothers tapping at 1:50 - 3:25, wearing white tuxedos with tails. The jackets are trying to fly off when the wave their arms during wings, and I swear you can see arms without full shirts.

Their 2nd and final appearance is at 24:40 - 26:00, dancing seated, enabling me to get screenshots of their faces.

They're not credited in the opening titles, but in the closing as Condos Brothers, in IMDb as Steve (b. 1918) and Nick (b. 1915), each with "(as Condos Brothers)" in their credit. N.B., IMDb has LOTS of credit info that does not appear onscreen. Hopefully most of it is taken from studio documents or other credible sources. But there's no way to know if these 2 brothers were named here by a fan who decided they recognized them, or if the credits come from a reliable source, say Nick's daughter. <sigh> I'll write about this more in a separate blog on the identification of these brothers; when complete I'll place a link here.

Choosing between names Nick and Steve, I choose Nick as the left one. In the prior routine he did the fast tap that should be the 5-point wing. The right face is younger, and Steve is under 20 when this is released. The 1990 (pre-internet) book Tap! by Rusty Frank has a few photos of Nick and Steve, and my choice agrees with labeling there.
At 1:17:00 we get many chorus girls dancing, perhaps justifying a Choreographer credit; it's very brief.

The plot involves Jack Haley being a good singer with stage experience in the hinterlands, who is convinced before his first NYC radio audition (by studio guard William Demarest) to be terrified of the mic. Alice Faye has a self-help radio show in the same building, and tries to help Jack past his phobia. The Bernie/Winchell feud pads the story.

Without the Condos Bros and AF singing, this would be a 5.

Fox, dir. Lanfield; 6-

Monday, December 11, 2017

Rosalie (1937), 6+

West Point cadet Dick Thorpe falls in love with a girl, who turns out to be a princess from an European kingdom.
(123 min) Released 1937-12-24
Director: W.S. Van Dyke (as W.S. Van Dyke II)
Stars: Nelson Eddy, Eleanor Powell, Frank Morgan, Edna May Oliver, Ray Bolger, Ilona Massey, Billy Gilbert, Reginald Owen.
Albertina Rasch ... dance and ensembles created by / dances and ensembles staged by
Dave Gould ... dance director: cadet routines (uncredited)

Genres: Drama | Musical

This is on a Warner Archive disc, so no scene menu, and chapter stops are at 10 min intervals. 

I can't believe they didn't make better use of Ray Bolger here. He doesn't have a full song to dance, just a seated bit at 1:23:30.

Just the significant Dancing:
  • [not] Who Knows? by EP & NE, other couples; just social dancing
  • 21:00 I've a Strange New Rhythm in My Heart, Sung and danced at Vassar dormitory by Eleanor Powell (dubbed by Marjorie Lane) with solo singing sections by others; **ugh! the director shoots EP dancing with only a closeup of her upper body! Not for all of it, but enough to aggravate me. 
  • 54:30 brief tease; Danced by the Albertina Rasch Dancers at the festival (impressive large number of dancers)
    • 59:30 Polovetsian Dances, Borodin
    • 1:07:10 (?)Caucasian Sketches, Op.10, Ippolitov-Ivanov 
    • Second Movement (Allegro con grazia), Tchaikovsky
  • 1:09:00 Rosalie by EP on giant drum-decorated platforms; impressive ending with all the AR dancers from the numbers above; looks like hundreds of moving humans in 1 shot; horrible camera platform shaking as they do very high-angle tracking away from the scene
  • 1:48:40 The Stars and Stripes Forever, Marched by Eleanor Powell and cadets at West Point, and danced by EP
The credits list 3 male specialty dancers. I didn't determine where they danced. Nor what the Parade was where the AR dancers were listed.

This is a Cole Porter score, but only this one stands out: 1:18:00 In the Still of the Night by NE, and I don't love his rendition: too stiff/operatic.

This reminds me of a Warner military school pic, with NE (b. 1901) even more ridiculously too old to be a senior in college than Dick Powell (b. 1904, and his last college student pic was in '35; so he was younger, had more of a baby face, and sang pop tenor instead of operatic baritone).

Recommended only for EP's dancing in the second hour, and this film is too long to recommend it for those minutes. However, the large group shots are not to be missed, including the final scene (which isn't a dance).

MGM, dir. Van Dyke; 6+

Love and Hisses (1937), 6-

As part of their public feud, Bandleader Bernie pretends a girl singer is no good so columnist Winchell promotes her in his column.
(82 min) Released 1937-12-21
Director: Sidney Lanfield
Stars: Walter Winchell, Ben Bernie, Simone Simon
Nick Castle ... choreographer
Geneva Sawyer ... choreographer

Genres: Comedy | Musical
Watched online, decent quality; part 1 was 41:52, part 2 was 42:58

This is a followup to Wake Up and Live ('37), which is mentioned early in this film ("you know them from WUAL", them being Winchell and Bernie, playing themselves.)

I was beginning to think the only justification for Musical was going to be Simone Simon's singing. Then in part 2, at 9:45, the radio broadcast begins (interrupted by story scenes):
  • Twins Barbara and Gloria Brewster sing Be A Good Sport 
  • Simone Simon sings Sweet Someone 
More of the broadcast continues from Ben Bernie's club with Broadway's Gone Hawaii at 27:40 (lasts until 34:00):
  • Ruth Terry sings
  • 24 chorus girls in tinsel grass skirts and top hats dance 
  • the Peters Sisters sing and dance (their feet make some tap movements, but no taps on these shoes)
  • specialty dance by Carol Chilton and Maceo Thomas (very athletic and artistic; their only other feature credit is Strike Me Pink ('36); they put this film on the Tap! Appendix. deservedly so.)
  • RT returns with chorus girls
I dislike the kidnapping plot; even fake kidnapping between friends is illegal and wrong. The Hawaii number saves this from being a 5.

Fox, dir. Lanfield; 6-

Oscar, Best Dance Direction, 1936-38


The Oscar for Best Dance Direction was awarded for only 3 years. Here are the winners and nominees, with links to my notes on the films.

Oscar 1936
WINNER: Dave Gould
NOMINEES
  • All the King's Horses: LeRoy Prinz For "Viennese Waltz".
  • The Big Broadcast of 1936: LeRoy Prinz For "Elephant - It's the Animal in Me".
  • Broadway Hostess: Bobby Connolly For "Playboy of Paree".
  • Go Into Your Dance: Bobby Connolly For "Latin from Manhattan".
  • Gold Diggers of 1935: Busby Berkeley For "Lullaby of Broadway" and "The Words Are in My Heart".
  • King of Burlesque: Sammy Lee For "Lovely Lady" and "Too Good to Be True".
  • She: Benjamin Zemach For "Hall of Kings".
  • Top Hat: Hermes Pan For "Piccolino" and "Top Hat".

Oscar 1937
WINNER: Seymour Felix
NOMINEES

Oscar 1938
WINNER: Hermes Pan
NOMINEES
Very disappointing that this award was discontinued, and no other arrived to honor choreographers in the decades of great musicals to come.

Sunday, December 10, 2017

Hollywood Hotel (1937), 6+

Ronny Bowers, a saxophonist in Benny Goodman's band has won a talent contest an got a ten week contract with a film studio. On his first evening he is supposed to go with the studio's star ... 
(109 min) Released 1937-12-20
Director: Busby Berkeley
Stars: Dick Powell, Rosemary Lane, Lola Lane, Hugh Herbert, Glenda Farrell, Johnnie Davis, Louella Parsons, Alan Mowbray, Frances Langford, Allyn Joslyn, Grant Mitchell, Edgar Kennedy, Benny Goodman, Gene Krupa, Harry James, Lionel Hampton, Teddy Wilson

Genres: Comedy | Musical | Romance

No, I didn't list the entire cast, just the majority of names I know. Also with a small part at 34:45, radio interviewer outside the movie premiere: wowser!, a very young, very handsome Ronald Reagan. He looks just a little taller than DP (they must be standing on different objects: DP 5'11, RR 6'1), but DP has a much bigger head.

Slogan at a studio entrance: Miracle Pictures - if it's a good picture it's a Miracle.

Whoa. I thought one Lane sister was playing a dual role. No, Rosemary plays the waitress and Lola the diva actress. They finally face off at the end, and LL has a more prominent nose? Looks a little older? Unfortunately they didn't face the camera together.
  • The opening scene is a parade of the Benny Goodman orchestra led by Johnnie Davis singing Hooray for Hollywood. I was surprised they kept the lyric with Donald Duck. A cartoon from Warner substituted Daffy Duck. You have to look carefully to find Harry James. He looks more geeky than suave; he obviously hadn't become a star player yet. Krupa is prominent.
  • 41:00 I'm Like a Fish out of Water sung by DP and RL in the fountain at the restaurant post-premiere party.
  • 57:20 Silhouetted in the Moonlight sung by RL in the shell of the Hollywood Bowl
  • 1:03:50 Let That Be a Lesson to You sung by JD with BG & Orch at Hollywood Hotel Orchid Room, sung by DP as carhop at drive-in restaurant, RL in a convertible, and more
  • 1:18:00 Sing, Sing, Sing by BG & Orch; Harry James is prominent for a few moments
  • 1:20:30 I've Got a Heartful of Music played by BG Quartet (Lionel Hampton, Teddy Wilson,  Krupa and BG)
  • 1:23:40 I've Hitched My Wagon to a Star sung by DP, dubbing for onscreen Alan Mowbry
  • At the Hollywood Hotel broadcast, all played by Raymond Paige and His Orchestra 
    • 1:33:40 Silhouetted in the Moonlight sung by FL, Jerry Cooper 
    • 1:38:30 Ochi Tchornya Sung by a chorus
    • 1:44:25 reprise I've Hitched My Wagon to a Star sung by DP
    • 1:46:10 Sing, You Son of a Gun sung by DP, JD, RL, GF, and more, with reprises of other songs so everyone can take their bow.
Sing, Sing, Sing is my favorite song of all time, especially the 12 minute version by BG & Orch at Carnegie Hall '38, which includes a sublime piano solo fairly near the end. (The link takes you to Amazon Prime for a free listen (use good speakers/headphones), free for how long I don't know; reviews complaining about wrong version... must have been fixed when I accessed it.) Ha, NPR has a year 2000 series of top 100 songs(?), moments in music history(?), and here's their 23 min on BG's Carnegie Hall concert (the first Swing band to play there), and SSS. They talk for 10 min, then play the track, talk for 1 more. Ugh, the NPR audio has the record scratches; not the Amazon track.

I'm sensing a pattern: when BB directs, he doesn't do ANY fancy dance sequences; ok, it's just a pattern of 2 movies. Director credits so far: 
Although there are better ways to consume BG music and get more of it for your time invested, it is a pleasure to see them perform.

Warner, dir. Berkeley; 6+

The 3 Lane Sisters, from imdb.com; blonde Priscilla was not in this film.
Which would you cast as the diva, which as the doe-eyed waitress?


Saturday, December 9, 2017

Every Day's a Holiday (1937), 6

Set in New York City, Mae West is Peaches O'Day, a con artist who befriends Captain Jim McCarey (Edmund Lowe), a cop who must turn her in unless she leaves town. The clever Peaches returns ... 
(80 min) Released 1937-12-18
Director: A. Edward Sutherland
Stars: Mae West, Edmund Lowe, Charles Butterworth, Lloyd Nolan, Charles Winninger, Louis Armstrong

Genres: Comedy | Music*mine
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0028843/

She wrote this one too. Only 2 more movies in this era (plus 1 in '70 and 1 in '78); only 1 more in this quest. Already makes me sad to move on. This is her 6th of 7 in this quest. She (b. '93) had 12 film credits total. Here she uses many familiar names and faces. (In other posts, I commented that she seemed to use only unfamiliar faces.)

This is the 2nd film in this quest with Louis Armstrong, both '37. He appears in 2 songs, playing his horn, leading the march, singing. So far, only 7 more of films with him are on this quest.

She plays an out-and-out grifter/thief. Her quaint little handbag contains all the tools a good burglar needs. She also stars in a stage show. Then she gets into politics. She plays drums in the parade too - full drum kit in an open car, and she's seated on a throne. The plot is a bit hard to follow.

Set yet again in the 1890s, her costumes, especially her hats, are fabulous. To disguise herself, she wears a black wig and different eye makeup, and sports a French accent, for part of the film; like Superman in glasses, it's hard to believe she's not recognized.

Emanuel Cohen Productions, distr. Paramount, dir. Sutherland; 6

A Damsel in Distress (1937), 7+

Lady Alyce Marshmorton must marry soon, and the staff of Tottney Castle have laid bets on who she'll choose, with young Albert wagering on "Mr. X." After Alyce goes to London to meet a beau...
(101 min) Released 1937-11-19
Director: George Stevens
Stars: Fred Astaire, George Burns, Gracie Allen, Joan Fontaine.
Hermes Pan ... dance director, Oscar winner for "Fun House"; Oscars 1938
Fred Astaire ... choreographer (uncredited)
Angela Blue ... assistant choreographer (uncredited)

Genres: Comedy | Musical | Romance
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0028757/

The plot is fine (although reviewers have complained at how much it strays from the Wodehouse novel). The young page (Harry Watson, b. 1921) and major domo Reginald Gardiner add lots of interest; the father (Montagu Love) is very good and Helen Westley is reliable in her usual cranky pompous Aunt role. Ray Noble, who plays Reggie, the local suitor and stepson of the aunt, has 88 soundtrack credits, mostly for writing music, with a handful of titles appearing repeatedly; this is 3rd of 7 acting credits, usually played Orchestra Leader; he also gets "additional arrangements" credit here. So he may actually be playing all those instruments in the film.

All these songs were written by the Gershwins:
  • 11:40 I Can't Be Bothered Now, Song and dance performed by Fred Astaire 
  • 24:30 The Jolly Tar and the Milkmaid, Performed by Pearl Amatore, Betty Rome, Jack George, Fred Astaire, Jan Duggan, Mary Dean, chorus 
  • 38:30 Put Me to the Test (I've Just Begun to Live), Dance performed by Fred Astaire, George Burns, Gracie Allen 
  • 47:30 The Fun House number: Stiff Upper Lip, Song performed by Gracie Allen, Dance performed by Fred Astaire, George Burns, Gracie Allen, chorus 
  • 1:04:00 Things Are Looking Up, Song performed by Fred Astaire, Dance performed by Fred Astaire, Joan Fontaine 
  • 1:08 Sing of Spring, Performed by Madrigal Singers 
  • 1:13:00 A Foggy Day, Performed by Fred Astaire 
  • 1:17:20 Nice Work If You Can Get It, Performed by Betty Rome, Jan Duggan, Mary Dean, Fred Astaire, Pearl Amatore 
  • 1:34:50 Nice Work If You Can Get It, Dance performed by Fred Astaire while playing the drums 
A Foggy Day and Nice Work If You Can Get It are the 2 familiar songs here. I love the trio of George & Gracie dancing with FA at 38:30; the fun house mirrors take away my enjoyment. George displayed some real skills here; looked to me that he was jumping higher than FA at some point.

Joan Fontaine is a definite weak link in the one dance she performs. It's strange to imagine how the film would have changed if Jessie Matthews, a highly capable and pleasing dancer, had accepted the invitation to play JF's role: which dance numbers would we have lost to gain her numbers? The love match certainly would have been more understandable between the 2 power dancers.

Don't tell Pan, but I would have given the Oscar to the Sonja Henie movie, Thin Ice, for the Prince Igor number. The camera angles, the occasional rush of speed, the large number of skaters somehow beats the fun house gimmicks for me. It also might be familiarity: I've seen this film more often than hers.

RKO, dir. Stevens; 7+

My post on Oscar, Best Dance Direction, 1936-38

Friday, December 8, 2017

Manhattan Merry-Go-Round (1937), 6-

Gangsters take control of a record company and use toughguy tactics on unwilling performers.
(89 min) Released 1937-11-26
Director: Charles Reisner (as Charles F. Reisner)
Stars: Phil Regan, Leo Carrillo, Ann Dvorak, James Gleason

Genres: Comedy | Music
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0029209/
Watched on Amazon Prime.

7 minutes in, and we get a great quote. Leo Carrillo plays a  gangster (with a Spanish/Italian accent, eventually we meet his Italian mamma), and James Gleason is his Runyonesque American gangland lieutenant (Brooklyn/Bronx, skinny, frail, late middle aged, but lively and twinkle-in-the-eye, straw hat, bow-tie demeanor). They've just foreclosed on a recording studio, taking over the business.

Cropped screen shot from video
Danny The Duck (Lt.): I can land enough talent in your lap to entertain the world.

Tony Gordoni (Boss): Yes, but I don't want them in my lap. I never mix business with pleasure.
Danny The Duck: Don't take me illiterately!


Frequently Tony Gordoni says "I am a man of very few words, and when I talk I say a lot." When we meet his mamma, she says her version, clearly the source of his.

Unfortunately, James Gleason quickly fades into the background, as usual.

This film is the least certain listing in Appendix B of Tap! by Rusty Frank, with the note "Possibly Cook and Brown." No one in the IMDb credits is named Cook or Brown, but it wouldn't be the first time a thorough cast list omitted dancers. (This one lists a ventriloquist's dummy: Elmer was played by Elmer.) I ran the movie a second time, trying to listen for taps, and got nothing, not even during Cab Calloway's Mama, I Wanna Make Rhythm. Some lively couples jitterbugging, but no taps; I wouldn't be surprised if CC's jitterbug partner was Jeni LeGon, but I wouldn't swear to it.

The best reason to watch this for me is that Kay Thompson and Her Ensemble sing 2 numbers: one starts around 20 minutes (video here; Amazon movie is better video quality), the other 43 minutes later. The credits list Hugh Martin and Ralph Blaine as 2 of her backup singers. These 2 are (future?) songwriters (sometimes together) and Kay, with Roger Edens, were the Freed unit's vocal arrangers, making many an MGM singer much better and more interesting than without them. (Edens especially worked with Judy Garland.)

I adore Kay Thompson's performance in Funny Face ('57); I think she steals the show from Fred Astaire and Audrey Hepburn. Unfortunately that was her only substantial acting credit. This film is her first of 4, the second looks like a bit part, and the last is in an early Liza Minnelli drama. If you think I'm enthusiastic about her, here's how her mini-bio on IMDb begins:
"Sleek, effervescent, gregarious and indefatigable only begins to describe the indescribable Kay Thompson -- a one-of-a-kind author, pianist, actress, comedienne, singer, composer, coach, dancer, choreographer, clothing designer, and arguably one of entertainment's most unique and charismatic personalities of the 20th century."
The author of that bio wrote many bios on the site,  seldom so effusive. (I guess 'coach' covers Vocal Arranger, for which she has the most credits. She was the author of the children's series of Eloise books about a 6 year old who lives at, and impacts the Plaza Hotel in NYC.) Kay actually appears as herself here, and has no lines beyond the songs she sings.

If you read the prior post for I'll Take Romance (different studio), you can imagine my disappointment when this film devolved into the recording company pursuing a diva opera singer to perform for them. And this one has lots of yelling. If only I had a dvd copy so I could ffwd while seeing where I am.

Louis Prima and his Band are listed as the background for one of Phil Regan's songs. I certainly wasn't aware of them while he sang. Ted Lewis and his band are quite prominent, but I don't recognize anything they play (nor any song from the film, but that's quite normal during this quest.)

The opening credits said "introducing" Gene Autry, but this is his 23rd film, starting in '34. Maybe it was a big deal for a singing cowboy to cross over to a mainstream film.

1:03:00 Kay Thompson does her brief second number in the recording studio, and they watch her on a television set (closed circuit, but not stated as such) down the hall in the office of the studio's president. Movies don't show working TVs very often, since it promoted the competition, but in '37 it wasn't widely available - or useful. (I remember what a big deal it was that Jane Wyman's character in Magnificent Obsession ('54) gets a TV set from her children, and she doesn't want it.)

Republic, dir. Reisner; 6-

I'll Take Romance (1937), 5

An opera manager tries to woo a contract-breaking soprano into performing in Buenos Aires.
(90 min) Released 1937-11-17
Director: Edward H. Griffith
Stars: Grace Moore, Melvyn Douglas, Helen Westley, Stuart Erwin, Margaret Hamilton

Genres: Musical | Romance
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0029043/
Watched online, really awful print visually, but ok audio.

Lots of good singing (opera arias). Typical deft performances by Douglas, Westley and Hamilton. Typical bumpkin from Erwin.

But, as the plot summary says, GM plays a singer who is such a diva (with the encouragement of her mentor(?) Westley) that she chooses to sing in Paris rather than B.A. Since trying to hold her to her contract is known to be futile because she will just claim she's ill, MD tries to cajole/trick/kidnap her into honoring his contract.

OK, but then he spends so much time with her that, despite her continued refusal to sing in B.A., MD falls in love with her. She thinks he's kidnapped her for love, so she's charmed. But when she discovers his financial motivation, she turns against him. He offers to cancel their contract just to prove his love for her. She performs under protest.

I don't care how it ended. I know she sings the title song, so I guess she capitulates romantically. Without the copious singing, this would be a "don't watch this again." Frankly, there are better ways to get a dose of opera, so I just talked myself into a 5.

Columbia, dir. Griffith; 5

Merry-Go-Round of 1938 (1937), 6-

Two screwy characters travel to Hollywood and cause mischief.
(87 min) Released 1937-11-14
Director: Irving Cummings
Stars: Bert Lahr, Jimmy Savo, Billy House, Mischa Auer, Alice Brady.

Genres: Comedy | Musical | Romance
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0029234/
Watched online, poor quality print.

This is sort of zany, but not zany enough for me. Apparently not for the person who wrote the plot summary either, because it was FOUR characters causing mischief in H'wood, not two: the 3 men in the poster (Auer on the left, then House and Savo) plus Bert Lahr not pictured. Alice Brady as a socialite they are trying to manipulate so their adopted daughter (exact custody not clear, but her mother was their friend and died when the daughter was an infant) can marry Brady's son. I was busy and waited a few hours to write this, and don't remember how it ends.

It's a musical because the men and the daughter are vaudeville performers, so they sing some, and move to the music some.

Probably the only reason this is 6- and not 5+ is that it was good to see Mischa Auer in a featured role, appearing throughout the film, equally important with the other 3. He usually is a minor if not bit player. He deserved better.

Universal, dir. Cummings; 6-

Thursday, December 7, 2017

Jericho, aka Dark Sands (1937), 8

During WWI, action hero Robeson escapes an unjust death sentence to ramble around Arabia.
(77 min) Released 1937-08-23
Director: Thornton Freeland
Stars: Paul Robeson, Henry Wilcoxon, Wallace Ford

Genres: Drama | Musical | Adventure

This was my favorite PR movie yet. Watching the featurette about his Brit films, his son says this was PR's fave of all his films. And I just watched 3 in a row (doing other stuff in between, but not watching movies/tv), and I'm ready for another. Unfortunately only 2 more left, and only 1 tagged "musical", released '40.

We start with PR in the American army, in a segregated black unit with a white commander (Wilcoxon) who values PR's contribution to the unit, and is helping him get more medical training. Although seeing the all-black unit set me on edge, bracing myself for racism to get ugly, I don't remember anything bad in that regard.

But bad things happen while PR is doing good, and PR's escape from injustice has bad consequences for HW. PR makes a new life for himself with new travel companion Ford. PR's leadership skills fully bloom. HW catches up with him, and their conflict resolves with great satisfaction to me (although it goes Fast, so don't look away, or you'll have to start that last chapter again).

I don't want to spoil the plot more than that. PR's presence is fully utilized, I don't remember racism being a thing, and they employed a lot of black actors for the beginning scenes. PR's character has great dignity and shows a full range of human emotions. I can't think of another actor so physically large and strong yet dignified, heroic, smart and warm. AND HE SINGS TOO.

I just made a note on his birthday that I should have a PR film festival. I have all 11 of his features, his only short as actor and the doc'y he narrated.

Buckingham Film Productions, Capitol Film Corporation, General Film Distributors, dir. Freeland; 8

Big Fella (1937), 7

In this musical comedy, Paul Robeson stars as Joe, a Marseilles docker hired by a wealthy English couple to find their missing son. When Joe finds him, he learns he escaped of his own will,...
(73 min) Released 1937-06-16
Director: J. Elder Wills
Stars: Paul Robeson, Elisabeth Welch, Roy Emerton

Genres: Drama | Musical
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0028629/

The cast and the story are engaging. We get Ms. Welch again, this time as a wannabe love interest. PR is as good with this child actor as with anything else. And it's nice to have him in a light story (although pity the parents, no matter how snooty: their son is missing, so far as they know!)

The cast is racially mixed, and very relaxed about it. The only overt reference to race comes at the last moment, and you can justify it by asking how else could the substitution be made.

Beaconsfield Productions, Hammer Films, distr. British Lion Film Corp, dir. Wills; 7

Song of Freedom (1936); 7-

A black British dockworker named Johnny Zinga becomes a famous singer and learns that he is the rightful king of the African island of Casanga.
(66 min) Released 1936-08-17
Director: J. Elder Wills
Stars: Paul Robeson, Elisabeth Welch, Esme Percy

Genres: Drama | Music
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0028282/

(This formerly on my list for a later year (US release instead of original release), but IMDb changed the List software yesterday, and 3 of his movies popped up higher. I wasn't going to fight the old sort; I like this better.)

The titular song is a familiar melody given how often I've watched this.

Adding to the plot summary, PR inherits the medallion stolen from the evil queen by her child. He also knows part of a song passed down to him over the hundred+ intervening years. He always yearns for his African roots, so when he makes enough money he and his wife go to the island to help "his people." Danger ensues. A convenient but plausible plot twist resolves the story.

Great usual presence of PR. Elisabeth Welch is a good choice for his strong supportive wife. Her 15 credits are in Brit films, so I don't know her from anything else. (Her 1 recognizable American credit says scenes deleted.)

I can argue with myself all day whether this is a 7- or a 6+, and then PR sings.

Hammer Films, distr. British Lion, dir. Wills; 7-




The Girl Said No (1937), 4+

Jimmy, a bookie cum horse buying agent, meets a beautiful dance hall girl. After leading him on, and out of his money, she rejects him. Jimmy hatches a scheme to wreak revenge on her. He ... 
(76 min) Released 1937-09-27
Director: Andrew L. Stone
Stars: Robert Armstrong, Irene Hervey, Paula Stone

Genres: Comedy | Musical
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0028931/
Watched online, poor quality. Re-release title: With Words and Music

All the players are unfamiliar (although American). The revenge plot was weird - was it proportional?

The Gilbert and Sullivan doesn't start until at least halfway through, maybe more. That part is ok, perhaps some is even cute, hence the +. But don't watch the rest of the flick.

Andrew L. Stone Productions, distr. Grand National, dir. Stone; 4+

Wednesday, December 6, 2017

Gangway (1937); 6+

Newspaper reporter becomes involved with gang of crooks who take her for a tough American gangster.
(90 min) Released 1937-08-20
Director: Sonnie Hale
Stars: Jessie Matthews, Barry MacKay, Nat Pendleton

Genres: Comedy | Crime | Musical
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0028918/
Watched online; ok print.

Part of the fun of this is the plot twists, so I won't spoil any more than the summary does. It's nice to see American Nat Pendleton here. Alistair Sim was also a welcome face.

JM dances, but less broadly than usual; the choreography is tame, even when she dances alone. And when she dances with a partner it's pathetic, but they acknowledge he's there as romantic interest, not dance partner. During one of the dances I felt she was antecedent to Carol Burnett because she was facially and physically mugging while dancing, which only shows her versatility.

Fortunately the crime theme involves gangsters who live the high life, so I get my quota of glamour. At one point JM wears a fur stole (that she, uh, borrowed) that's in a butterfly shape. Gorgeous; never saw one like that before. But the open shoulders likely make it a poor comfort against the night air.

I'm already wanting to own the complete JM catalog. That's tough given the lack of interest, even in GB. I already bought Evergreen on amazon.co.uk (cheaper!), but the quality was public domain. I didn't find any claiming to be a restoration, or an official studio release. (I did watch a British doc'y about her and how neglected is her dancing legacy; she's remembered more for the radio soap she did late in life, and even that's fading.)

Director Sonnie Hale was JM's husband 1931-44.

Gaumont British Picture Corporation; dir. Hale; 6+

Ali Baba Goes to Town (1937), 7+

A movie company is doing the Arabian Nights when a hobo enters their camp, falls asleep and dreams he's back in Baghdad as advisor to the Sultan. In a spoof of Rosevelt's New Deal, he ... 
(81 min) Released 1937-10-15
Director: David Butler
Stars: Eddie Cantor, Tony Martin, Roland Young, Gypsy Rose Lee, Raymond Scott and His Quintet, John Carradine, Douglass Dumbrille.
Sammy Lee ... dances staged by; Oscar nom'd for "Swing Is Here to Stay"; Oscars 1938

Genres: Comedy | Fantasy | Musical
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0028566/

This is the last of the seven Cantor star-vehicles I own, and the highest ranked by IMDb users (they give it an 8, also Palmy Days, which I give 6 despite Charlotte Greenwood as the star and EC absent from the first 4 credits.) This is 1 of 3 of his films that I actually liked, and the best 2 were his only Fantasy genre (he falls asleep and dreams the bulk of the movie). The other Fantasy is Roman Scandals ('33; 7-), which only gets 7.4 IMDb average, and ranks 6th among the seven. (My third 'like' of the Cantor films, Strike Me Pink ('36; 7-) co-started E.Merman, who contributed a lot to my enjoying the film, and is last of the seven for IMDb voters, with average score of 7.)

Here I like that he brings his '30s cultural references and political ideas to the ancient Bagdad society, and I like the opulent royal court where most of the movie exists (the bejeweled costumes look heavy!) The Raymond Scott music is a huge bonus, probably what elevates this to a +.

Tony Martin sports a mustache here; it looks better than clean-shaven; wonder why he didn't adopt it. Gypsy Rose Lee is good as the Sultana, but again doesn't perform, just acts. She only has 2 Soundtrack credits (in '44 and '58), so I wonder if we ever get to see her strut her stuff in a film.

Charles Lane (1905–2007) has a bit part as a Doctor. He has 239 movie credits ('30-'87) and 123 TV credits ('51-'95), which just counts shows, not episodes. If you've watched anything from those decades, you likely know his face.

This movie earned an entry in Appendix B of the book Tap! with the scene at 34:00 (the enveloping scene is the Oscar nom'd Swing Is Here to Stay, which begins at 29:00) with Jeni LeGon and the Peters Sisters tapping (and PS singing). Jeni (in slacks) danced along side Bill Robinson in Hooray for Love ('35) and will appear in a few more films on this quest. The Peters Sisters appeared in With Love and Kisses ('36), the film with Pinky Tomlin and Toby Wing. PS have only 5 American credits (plus 6 European), and right now their other American films are online; one is not a musical.

The Oscar nom is likely for the entire scene, since the musicians move a lot too.

Raymond Scott and His Quintet appear in the acting credits, and twice in the Soundtracks:
Twilight in Turkey (1937) 
Written by Raymond Scott
Performed by Raymond Scott and His Quintet (uncredited),


corrected to include Danced by The Pearl Twins
Beginning at 57:00 we see 6 musicians well-hidden by beards (is RS the one with the finger cymbals?), playing as the Pearl Twins dance.
Arabania (1937) (uncredited)
Music by Harry Revel
Lyrics by Mack Gordon
Performed by Raymond Scott and His Quintet
Danced by The Pearl Twins
OK, this is wrong, because the tune danced by the Pearl Twins is VERY Raymond Scott-y (and no one sang any lyrics). He composed Powerhouse (listed 50 times in his Soundtrack credits, the first was in a '40 live-action Warner musical short; the rest are probably all Warner cartoons). Even if I were only familiar with Powerhouse (and I'm not, I own an album of his), I would recognize (like you recognize Mozart without knowing which piece it is) the music danced by the Pearl Twins as his, and I don't think you get there just from arrangement. Aha! Twilight in Turkey is on the album I have, and that's what the Twins dance; I'll submit a correction; correction was accepted. After the Twins dance, a larger group of dancers performs to a different tune also played by the sextet, and that is more likely to be not his (but it could be). Then in a scene after the harem dancing, when EC is tying up DD, the music sounds Scott-y again. 

Note that this is not a Goldwyn film, as were the prior six.

Fox, dir. Butler; 7+

My post on Oscar, Best Dance Direction, 1936-38


Say It with Songs (1929), 6+

Joe Lane kills another man in a fistfight after learning that the man has made improper advances towards his wife. Joe goes to prison for the murder. When Joe gets out of prison, he visits ... 
(95 min) Released 1929-08-06
Director: Lloyd Bacon
Stars: Al Jolson, Davey Lee, Marian Nixon

Genres: Musical
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0020366/

By '29 the awkwardness of sound recording really was smoothing out. The unfamiliarity of these faces still jumps out (NO one on the cast list is familiar after AJ); it's like a PovRow/indie production several years later. (I was analyzing Columbia musicals in more detail today, and they had a lot with "stars" I don't know. In the genre Musicals, Columbia was not a major studio.)

Jolson is great with the child, the same actor as The Singing Fool ('28); the kid has only 6 credits, so this is likely my last view of him. Marian Nixon is new to me, plays AJ's wife, and has 74 film credits ('23-'36); this one is about halfway on her list, is the only one I own, and I've rated one other (a 5 in my Netflix days).

The story is rather sad, as the plot summary above suggests. AJ sings on the radio (his job before prison), he sings in prison (to sooth the savage breast), and he's broadcasting on radio from there. Things get really ugly when he gets out of jail, so AJ has plenty of opportunity to act. We get plenty of plot, and a bit of a surprise at the end.

Warner, dir. Bacon; 6+

Tuesday, December 5, 2017

Heidi (1937), 6 {nm}

A plucky little orphan girl gets dumped abruptly into her gruff, hermit grandfather's care, then later gets retaken and delivered as a companion for an injured girl.
(88 min) Released 1937-10-15
Director: Allan Dwan
Stars: Shirley Temple, Jean Hersholt, Arthur Treacher

Genres: Drama | Family | Musical

Should NOT be classified a musical. ST spends a few minutes acting out a story being told about a Dutch girl in wooden shoes with other children (also clad in wood) who then imagines she's in a European royal court doing a minuet-y dance with her pals, then back to Holland, then back to Heidi. I remember her singing a hymn, but not for long.

As an ST movie, it's fine. She's the usual orphan who's passed around like chattel, and she wins over most of the crusty adults. I don't understand the appeal of orphan stories. Did parents use it to control their children? Did it make adults feel better if they hadn't been orphans? Did people like the idea of detaching themselves from familial ties (they WANTED to be orphans)? Did it help parents justify a) keeping their children despite the financial burden, or b) that turning their kid(s) over to an orphanage wouldn't be a disaster because look at how well-adjusted ST is?

No wonder I don't have a strong image of Jean Hersholt. He's behind so much stage hair, he doesn't make any facial impression beyond wig and whiskers.

Fox, dir. Dwan; 6

Something to Sing About (1937), 6

A New York bandleader journeys to Hollywood when he is offered a contract with a studio, but he is determined to do things his way and not theirs.
(93 min) Released 1937-09-30
Director: Victor Schertzinger
Stars: James Cagney, Evelyn Daw, William Frawley
Harland Dixon ... dance stager
Angela Blue ... choreographer (uncredited)

Genres: Comedy | Musical
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0029588/
Watched online at Amazon Prime, saving me from having to find the disc in my Public Domain binder. Oh, no. The end credits listed dancers in a scene I don't remember. And on my BluRay player's app, Amazon doesn't show the video as you fast forward. So I had to pull out the dvd anyway. (BTW, the Amazon video quality was no better, and possibly a little worse, than my Treeline dvd.)

Cagney dancing is a great thing, and he works a staircase here as he will in Yankee Doodle Dandy ('42); see the dance beginning at 4 minutes in, lasts 2+ min. We get more dancing at the very end of the film (about t-2 minutes). At 39:20 starts a dance/comedy routine among the tramp steamer (his honeymoon ship) crew, which Cagney joins; duration 2.4 min.

The fight scene at about 28 min is fun. Philip Ahn as JC's Hollywood body man is written and played very well.

The quantity of dancing is insufficient to make my "worthwhile dancing" list. But it makes the movie better by its inclusion. He sings a little too.

Zion Meyers Productions, distr. Grand National, dir. Schertzinger; 6

Varsity Show (1937), 5

Winfield College students who are trying to put together the annual varsity show come into conflict with their faculty adviser, a stodgy old professor whose ideas are hopelessly out of date... 
(120 min) Released 1937-09-04
Director: William Keighley
Stars: Dick Powell, Fred Waring and His Pennsylvanians, Ted Healy, Rosemary and Priscilla Lane, Johnie Davis, Buck and Bubbles, Lee Dixon.
Busby Berkeley ... creator: finale / director: finale; Oscar nom'd; Oscars 1938
Genres: Musical

DP and Fred Waring are credited above the title, others through Buck & Bubbles are credited after, Lee Dixon not until post-film titles. There must be a (sad) story behind the fall. He appears throughout the film, but has no featured dance. 

This is Johnie Davis' first of 13 credits; 3 more appear on this quest. His singing, especially of Hooray for Hollywood in Hollywood Hotel ('37) iu quite welcome. Each Lane sister gets a song and plenty of plot; this is the first of PL's 22 credits (last in '48).

This list of Musical numbers is not worth reading:
  • Ch 2: We're Working Our Way Through College sung by ensemble walking through campus
  • Ch 3: Old King Cole sung by JD rehearsing the varsity show in the gym; B&B, as janitors, turn the plot by suggesting DP is needed to shape the Varsity Show, but they kowtow 
  • Ch 7: We're Working Our Way Through College sung by DP and ensemble on Senior Walk
  • Ch 9: I'm Dependable sung by PL and FW at a school dance
  • Ch 10: On With the Dance sung by RL at the same dance
  • Ch 11: You've Got Something There sung by DP to RL on an evening campus walk
  • Ch 13: You've Got Something There danced by John Bubbles in a school boiler room
  • Ch 19: Have You Got Any Castles, Baby? sung briefly by PL & ensemble in dress rehearsal
  • Ch 20: Buck and Bubbles medley in off-white top hat and tails, mostly danced by Bubbles; the pair are alone on stage; are Buck's clothes always poorly fit?
  • Ch 21: Finale medley, military drill
  • Ch 22: Finale college songs, lots of reverse footage to "precision" letter forming
  • Ch 23 of 23: Finale, Love Is on the Air Tonight, now the entrance footage in reverse
I can't believe the Finale was Oscar nom'd; could only be for Berkeley's prior work.

No matter how cheerful the cast, this is one dreary film. I ran it more than once. I slept in between. If I hadn't made the scene list before watching the film, this blog would be a lot shorter. I'm pushing my rating down to a 5. The only reason to put this in the player is for ch 20, and that's not worth the effort either. Whatever contributions Bubbles made to the evolution of tap, they are either subtle, or just absent here. (And yes, B&B's dancing scenes could easily be excised by the regions that did such things. When they appear in the story, they are very deliberately submissive.)

The cartoon Have You Got Any Castles?, included as a bonus feature (also on GC2), is nice, does the song more justice, and includes a nice Bill Robinson moment.

Warner; dir. Keighley; 5

My post on Oscar, Best Dance Direction, 1936-38

Thin Ice (1937), 7+

A Swiss hotel's ski instructor falls in love with a man who goes skiing every morning.
(79 nub) Released 1937-04-01
Director: Sidney Lanfield
Stars: Sonja Henie, Tyrone Power, Arthur Treacher
Harry Losee ... dances stager, Oscar nom'd for "Prince Igor Suite"; Oscars 1938
Jack Pfeiffer ... assistant dance director (uncredited)

Genres: Comedy | Musical | Romance
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0029659/

2nd of 10 Henie musicals; 1st of 2 with Tyrone Power (1914–1958), his 9th of 51 credits. Cute but not unusual plot (mistaken identity, poor girl falls for prince). SH plays the hotel skating instructor.

The staging of the skating really stepped up (from the first film) in the Oscar-nom'd number; the finale would fit in with the prior film routines. All the skating:

  • 14:30 SH practices for 30 seconds without music
  • 33:30 The Oscar-nom'd Prince Igor Suite (actually Polovetsian Dances from "Prince Igor" by Aleksandr Borodin, the same music used as a basis for songs in Kismet ('55)). I paused the film, and estimate 40 men and 40 women skating in various formations, often at a fast pace, in support of our star. Various camera angles provide a reflection in the nightclub ceiling, on-ice waist-high views of SH and of long lines of skaters speeding past each other and the camera, and other views. The dance lasts 6 minutes. I don't remember the Oscar-winning dance well enough to make a judgement yet, but it's hard to believe anything is better than this. Watch with full attention, and it is thrilling.
  • 51:20 Ensemble comes onto the ice in couples as though seated in the audience, but then cooperate in a large formation, leading into
  • 52:50 SH skates The Blue Danube Waltz by Johann Strauss with 6 men pairing with her for 3.5 minutes.
  • 1:15:10 The 40 men and 40 women give us some formations before circling the rink to watch SH skate more magic to Over Night for 2 min, as the finale. Strange that the other 2 numbers have plain white floors, but the finale has large checkered tiles, but the surrounding audience setting and the neon "fountain" are the same.
Be careful skipping the Joan Davis songs; they both precede skating, and on this good-quality bootleg copy the chapter stops have no logic.

The skiing scenes are nicely done, but only noteworthy because of the bad versions done with rear projection in other films. No attempt here to show closeups during motion, just well-cut shushes to stationary actors.

Fox, dir. Lanfield; 7+

My post on Oscar, Best Dance Direction, 1936-38

Monday, December 4, 2017

The Firefly (1937), 7+

Nina Maria Azara is the beautiful and alluring singing spy for Spain during the Napoleonic Wars. Her mission is to seduce French Officers, in order for them to reveal Napolean's intentions ... 
(131 min) Released 1937-09-01
Director: Robert Z. Leonard
Stars: Jeanette MacDonald, Allan Jones, Warren William.
Albertina Rasch ... dances

Genres: History | Musical | Romance
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0028873/

The original home of The Donkey Serenade, Allan Jones' signature song. Flute version in chapter 9, AJ sings in ch 10, reprise in ch 40 of 40.

Lots of good singing, and JM dances well. Because the context of the that time (dusty travel in stagecoach) and of war, with JM playing an entertainer in taverns, and AJ is a soldier, it's not a pleasant light-hearted romp. That's not bad, but it's probably what holds me back from giving it an 8, because I adore both AJ and JM, and they are very good here.

MGM, dir. Leonard; 7+

Double or Nothing (1937), 6+

According to the will of an eccentric millionaire, one of four randomly chosen strangers will become his heir if he/she can double $5000 by honest means.
(90 min) Released 1937-09-01
Director: Theodore Reed
Stars: Bing Crosby, Martha Raye, Andy Devine.
LeRoy Prinz ... choreographer

Genres: Comedy | Musical | Romance
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0028806/

The plot is a little more interesting than usual, and is mostly coherent. Probably the most fun moment requires suspension of logic check, but the fun is worth it.

In chapter 4 we got a bonus dance moment, when a motorcycle cop cuts in on BC's date dance on the sidewalk, and then does a solo tap number - slowly - but doing some of those moves slowly looks like it takes a lot of control and skill; actor's name: James Notaro, with only 16 credits, mostly as a dancer, always uncredited (except this one), but in a lot of movies I own.

While the whole movie is pretty good overall, the pace really picks up starting in chapter 11 of 19, where we get musical numbers and/or specialty acts nearly one after the other at the nightclub BC created. The costumes and sets are very pretty too. The uniform of the Sing Orchestra, with the bejeweled custom instrument badges, is especially nice. (I couldn't figure out the actor who draped the samples on the models; it felt like he was a real designer.)

The comic adagio couple, Ames and Arno, is fun, as are the slo-mo Calgary Brothers. None of the songs became standards, but a couple are very pleasant, especially when sung by Bing.

Martha Raye (1916–1994) has 26 movie credits, 19 are music/musical. This is the 3rd and final with Bing. She does 4 with Bob Hope, all in the next 2 years.

Paramount, dir. Reed; 6+

Sunday, December 3, 2017

Make a Wish (1937), 5-

While at summer camp in the Maine woods, little Bobby Breen befriends composer Basil Rathbone, who left the city to try and break his creative block, and is soon playing matchmaker for his ... 
(77 min) Released 1937-08-27
Director: Kurt Neumann
Stars: Bobby Breen, Basil Rathbone, Marion Claire

Genres: Comedy | Musical
Watched on Amazon Prime

This is my last Bobby Breen movie, and my last blurry public domain film - unless I have a compelling reason to watch. My first instinct was not to watch them, then I found a couple that were pretty good, but now I've lost my patience for it. It hurts a lot that the audio was bad too.

Here the compulsion might have been to see Basil Rathbone in a musical, but he doesn't sing or dance, so it's just standard Breen stuff.

The poster is very informative: the child dominates the story, just like in a ST movie. And I don't like children with the full burden on their shoulders. (I know, I'm repeating myself.) The kid sings well, but let's give some adults a chance to dazzle instead.

Oh yeah, I forgot about his production deal (I never looked for how it worked.)

Bobby Breen Productions + Sol Lesser Productions / distr. RKO, dir. Neumann; 5-

Update 8Aug2020: bought a copy (public domain). I'm much happier with it today, because I haven't been watching musicals/30s films, so I'm thrilled to see D.Meek, L.Erroll+others, B.Rathbone against type, plus SONGS. Both this and Let's Sing Again ('36, watched y'day) do remind me of S.Temple stories. Upgrade to  6.0 (130); 6.

Saturday, December 2, 2017

Broadway Melody of 1938 (1937), 6+

Steve Raleight wants to produce a show on Broadway. He finds a backer, Herman Whipple and a leading lady, Sally Lee. But Caroline Whipple forces Steve to use a known star, not a newcomer. ... 
(110 min) Released 1937-08-20
Director: Roy Del Ruth
Stars: Robert Taylor, Eleanor Powell, George Murphy, Buddy Ebsen, Judy Garland, Sophie Tucker.
Dave Gould ... dance ensembles

Genres: Musical | Romance

I was surprised by my prior rating of 6 ... until I watched it again. Now I have a big additional reason: A Day at the Races was released 6'37, this in 8'37. Both were in development in '36, because Thalberg died 9'36 and both list him as executive producer on IMDb (he never allowed himself to be listed onscreen.) So... HOW does no one see the plot parallels: racehorse injures front leg tendon, owner discovers the horse is a better jumper than flat racer, horse recovers in time to enter the big race, horse hates the sound of a certain voice and runs faster, winning purse is needed to (save the sanitarium *or* put on that B'way show). 

My other plot quibble is that our 3 principle dancers all come together over this injured horse; and not only are they experts on tending/riding racehorses, but they're expert tap dancers too. I know I'm supposed to suspend disbelief for musicals, but both pursuits consume a great deal of time, and very few stables have floors suitable for tapping (although one did in the Shirley Temple/Bill Robinson film The Little Colonel (1935); horsey anecdote from there: BR worked as a stable boy at age 8, also danced for pennies then. BR seemed especially comfortable with horses In Old Kentucky ('35). And since EP spent some formative career time with BR, that would almost make me suspect this is a nod to him, but I don't think EP would've had that much plot influence.)

Ugh: the guy who analyzed snores (in the prior B'way M'dy? I ain't gonna look for it) is back, analyzing sneezes. BoRRRing.

Judy Garland (1922–1969) in her 2nd feature credit. You can see her being molded by the 3 musical scenes below. She's treated as younger than her age, even though she's adult height and her singing is adult+professional. Sophie Tucker (1884–1966) plays her mother and former vaudevillian.

Carole Landis is in the credits as a chorus girl. Didn't see her.

Musical numbers:
  • Ch 2: The Toreador Song, sung in a barbershop, hooking in 2 characters who'll turn the tide twice later
  • Ch 6: Follow in My Footsteps, sung and tapped in the boxcar/stable/sleeping quarters for the trainers BE, GM, EP. Seems like the 2 horses would make things smelly. Plus there's a giant mucking shovel tacked to the wall to remind us of a little reality: anti-glamour.
  • Ch 8: Yours and Mine, played on piano by songwriter RT and sung by EP's dubber in empty bar-car
  • Ch 10: Everybody Sing, JG gets a specialty, a spontaneous audition outside a producer's office
  • Ch 15: Some of These Days, ST gets her first trip down memory lane at rehearsal
  • Ch 18: I'm Feelin' Like a Million. GM & EP celebrate their purchase of the horse, sung and danced in a park in the rain, sometimes in a gazebo, sometimes getting wet. (Where is the person who should've said 'this has been done'? At one point they even do a triple-hop. Makes you appreciate Astaire's memory and insistence that he never repeat himself.) When they kick the water in the puddle, remember that Gene Kelly hasn't arrived in H'wood yet. And when they steal the vendor's umbrella, karma is right around the puddle. GM looks like he got a mouthful when they're neck-deep at the end: anti-glamour.
  • Ch 20: Largo al Factotum. Now the barber auditions for the B'way producer in NYC. But the horse is recuperating in the back yard, doesn't like opera, and jumps the fences.
  • Ch 22: Dear Mr. Gable. JG's 2nd specialty.
  • Ch 29: Your Broadway and My Broadway, Powell/Murphy. Romantic dancing in the show. EP's dress looks adapted from a prior antebellum epic, without the hoops. But the stage is all skyscrapers and model cars driving in the background.
  • Ch 30: Your Broadway and My Broadway, Garland/Ebsen. JG looks uncomfortable dancing, but she gets to be great at it in the future. JG's dress is a cut-down version of what EP was wearing, looks like something Shirley Temple wears, but she was born in '28!.
  • Ch 31: Your Broadway and My Broadway. ST does her reminiscing within the show. There are several neon signs on set with her real name, not her character's.
  • Ch 32: Follow in My Footsteps: starts with BE, GM & EP in top hat and tails with chorus boys, but soon she's left alone to do what she does best. Now the neon signs invoke various B'way stars. (I LOVE those little moving model cars in the background giving scale to the skyscrapers.) 
  • Ch 33 of 33: Broadway Rhythm and finale: Chorus boys return, and here come the rest of the antebellum gowns. Snippets from prior B'way M'dy songs. And EP shows off her gymnastic skills. The very end is very silly, also feels stolen from A Day at the Races.
Note to self: when you balk at the lack of transition from horserace to B'way show, from EP having quit the show to being its star, remember that the filmmakers simply failed to give you a montage to show the reconciliation and rehearsal in between. Why should they have to? Y'knew EP had to be a musical star, because she is.

Hopefully I run into a GM movie where he's the stronger dancer on stage. He looks intimidated and under-rehearsed. like he's thinking about the next step instead of enjoying the glory of escorting EP. I'm actually distracted by him when they dance together. Of his 44 films, 16 are music/musicals. He had some lesser pairings already, but I wasn't watching for that. I will in the future, including his powerhouse pairings with EP, FA and Gene Kelly.

Like F&G movies, I hold EPs to a higher standard. That's a little silly, because FA was a bigger fish, and in a smaller pond, so he was able to exert more control. And MGM didn't know how to make a good musical until EP arrived, so the fact that they're imitating others shouldn't surprise; they're playing catchup, and paddling as fast as they can, trying to ride the wake of Warner and RKO.

Same complaint here as F&G's Follow the Fleet ('36): this one had too little GLAMOUR. I love the F&G films not just because of their dancing, but because of the glorious, famous, big white rooms and fabulous clothes. Gimme opulence, baby; the sleeker the better. That's why I favor '30s movies; they take audiences to fantasyland for American working class. America didn't go socialist, and the lottery is so popular, because the American dream is to strike it rich and live like the 1%. I just like to watch.

With this much EP dancing, I gotta tack on a +.

MGM, dir. Del Ruth; 6+

Friday, December 1, 2017

Artists & Models (1937), 6+

Mac Brewster (Benny) is head of an advertising firm that is in debt. The million-dollar Townsend Silver contract could save the firm, but the wealthy playboy Alan Townsend (Arlen) wants an ... 
(97 min) Released 1937-08-04
Director: Raoul Walsh
Stars: Jack Benny, Ida Lupino, Richard Arlen, Gail Patrick.
Vincente Minnelli ... staging director: "Public Melody No. 1"
LeRoy Prinz ... musical numbers staged by

Genres: Comedy | Musical
http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0028587/

I like Ida Lupino and Gail Patrick (in general, and here.) GP doesn't play a be-atch this time, but she is a society dame. Hedda Hopper acts, playing the wise-cracking aunt (or some such), but with little screen time. BTW, Jack Benny (1894-1974) was already well-past his 39th birthday in 1937.

Wow, the Soundtracks list a bunch of songs and only 1 has any performer attached; I submitted changes:
  • Ch 3: opening number by Yacht Club Boys about Sasha Pasha, a stupendous producer, with wardrobe borrowed by both versions of Max Bialystock in The Producers (1967 and 2005). This was absent from the Soundtracks.
  • Ch 5: Pop Goes the Bubble, sung by Judy Canova in the tub
  • Ch 6: no title for the music, but there's a circus being performed in JB's office
  • Ch 7: Whispers in the Dark, sung by Connie Boswell w/ Andre Kostelanetz and his orchestra, 2 sync'd swimmers (where? perhaps in the moat around the orchestra? We only see them in 2-shots, above and under water). The singer is kept in the dark because of the lyrics?
  • Ch 8: Stop You're Breaking My Heart, sung by JC, danced by JC & Ben Blue. This song is used a lot in the score, with different arrangement(s?).
  • Ch 9: Mister Esquire, danced by Ben Blue and Patterson's Personettes (marionettes); I like the instruments playing themselves, and the model luxury building
  • Ch 11: Jesse James (folk song, absent from the Soundtracks) by Canova trio
  • Ch 12: Public Melody No. 1,  sung by Martha Raye in tropical makeup on Harlem street scene w/black actors, played & recited by Louis Armstrong   (staging this is Vincente Minnelli's first film credit) 

  • I Have Eyes ??
  • Moonlight and Shadows ??
  • Found both songs on YouTube from Artie Shaw w/ Helen Forrest, and Bing Crosby respectively, and still can't locate them in the movie.
The musical interludes make little sense; some are tied to the characters, others are not. But if they entertain, numbers can just exist. And most of these do entertain (the Bubbles bug me; use FFWD since nextChapter skips too much.) And I like the sets and costumes. I ran the movie several times over the day because I was doing other things.

Paramount, dir. Walsh; 6+

You Can't Have Everything (1937), 6+

Starving playwright Judith Wells meets playboy writer of musicals, George Macrae, over a plate of stolen spaghetti. He persuades producer Sam Gordon to buy her ridiculous play "North Winds"... 
(100 min) Released 1937-08-03
Director: Norman Taurog
Stars: Alice Faye, The Ritz Brothers, Don Ameche, Gypsy Rose Lee, Arthur Treacher, Tony Martin, Louis Prima.
Harry Losee ... choreographer

Genres: Comedy | Musical | Romance
Bootleg copy, decent quality. This print is 5 minutes shorter than IMDb says; maybe that's why we get only 1 number from Tip Tap & Toe, instead of the 2 listed in the Soundtracks.

This is the 3rd of 4 movies that AF and TM did together '36-'38. They were married 9'37-3'41. 

Too bad Gypsy (1911-70) doesn't perform here; she has a straight comedramatic role. This is her first of 12 films.

The Ritz Brothers have some lines, and make non-comedy faces too. Nothing here is as good as their astronomer production in On the Avenue ('37), but that shines more for the dancing than the comedy. 

Director Taurog has directing credits for 9 of Elvis' 31 movies ('60-'68), 79 movies total ('28-'68) and 103 shorts ('20-'31).

We do get onstage production numbers, sometimes in rehearsal, sometimes partial, hence the credit for choreographer.

Musical numbers, to determine the "missing" Tip Tap & Toe dance:
  • 5:20 You Can't Have Everything, sung by Alice Faye with David Rubinoff on violin, in restaurant when she can't pay for her spaghetti
  • 23:10 Long Underwear, sung and danced by The Ritz Brothers and chorus in half-dress rehearsal
  • 29:20 The Loveliness of You, sung by Tony Martin and showgirls in rehearsal
  • 37:18 (not in credits) sounds like a brief Sing, Sing, Sing played by Louis Prima as our stars enter the dive bar
  • 39:55 Danger, Love at Work, sung and danced (a little) by Alice Faye with Louis Prima and His Band in dive bar
  • 46:50 You Can't Have Everything, reprised by The Ritz Brothers with Louis Prima and His Band in the dive bar (what's with the boots?) The boots are distracting, since I worry for the safety of Jimmy/Al having to dance on/around them.
  • 57:10 Afraid to Dream, sung by Don Ameche in rehearsal
  • 1:02:00 Afraid to Dream, reprised by Alice Faye, Tony Martin and chorus in dress rehearsal
  • 1:15:20 Please Pardon Us, We're in Love, sung by Alice Faye back home working in music shop
  • 1:20 Tip Tap & Toe dance to something at the beginning of opening night. One of them is dressed as some royalty? The 2 credits are It's a Southern Holiday and Rhythm of the Radio, both mentioning "played by Louis Prima and His Band", and LP is not visible here. No lyrics, so...? Great dancing. Lots of sliding joins the taps.
  • 1:24:20 North Pole Sketch, performed by The Ritz Brothers, Tony Martin, Dorothy Christy and others 
  • and various reprises

Fox, dir. Taurog; 6+